“While many suggest the insurance and annuity industry have been steady and reliable … it is also known to be slow to change. Over the last decade, that narrative is changing. Both from a volume and velocity perspective”
Colin Lake,
Delaware Life Marketing
“There is a tremendous amount of increased flexibility, not only for the advisors but also the clients”
Brian Nicolarsen,
Jackson National Life Insurance
In Partnership with
Annuities are selling.
Now comes the harder sell
Delaware Life’s Colin Lake explains how product innovation and closer advisor collaboration could help sustain the industry’s impressive growth
Read on
Brian Nicolarsen
Jackson National Life Insurance
Belle Carter
MassMutual Ascend
Colin Lake
Delaware Life Marketing
Industry experts
AN INDUSTRY whose sales have roughly doubled in a decade has little reason to ask why some buyers keep walking away. Colin Lake, president and CEO of Delaware Life Marketing, asks anyway. He cites LIMRA’s Secure Retirement Institute, which found that among advisors who described the annuity sales process as difficult, 63 percent cited overly complex product designs as a reason.
That reluctance is particularly consequential as the US enters the peak years of its retirement wave. More than 4.1 million Americans are expected to turn 65 annually through 2027, according to the Alliance for Lifetime Income. Yet only 24 percent of baby boomers reaching retirement age have defined benefit pensions, leaving a growing population to manage retirement income largely through Social Security and personal savings.
Lake believes the industry’s success has encouraged some manufacturers to stick with familiar products rather than address those objections. Strong sales have made that approach commercially defensible, even as they leave a potentially valuable segment of the advisory market underserved.
that requires separate compensation arrangements or cannot be folded into existing client accounts. Nicolarsen says that without fee-based annuities the channel is effectively closed to carriers, given the fiduciary framework advisors work within.
Fee-based contracts have begun to close that gap. Lake estimated that sales have doubled since 2020, though from a small base.
At MassMutual Ascend, Carter has seen that interest turn into business. The company recently reached $2 billion in its fee-based annuity segment after about 10 years in the market, she says, with a notable share of that coming in the past 16 months. Ascend was the first carrier to offer a fee-based fixed indexed annuity (FIA), and she credits the peers that followed for pushing carriers to modernize.
During a recent InvestmentNews discussion, Lake joined Brian Nicolarsen, head of distribution enablement at Jackson National Life Insurance, and Belle Carter, key account manager, RIA, at MassMutual Ascend, to discuss how insurers are trying to broaden their reach.
Winning a place in the advisory portfolioFixed indexed annuities (FIAs) and registered index-linked annuities (RILAs) account for much of the recent growth, since both limit or remove principal loss while leaving room to beat inflation. Lake says the company has adjusted its own designs accordingly. One FIA feature adds a guaranteed minimum rate of return when the client chooses a diversified index portfolio.
The registered investment advisor (RIA) market shows why annuity manufacturers have struggled to grow beyond their established distribution networks. An RIA may see the value of guaranteed retirement income and still have reasons to pass on a product
Carter describes much of the improvement as renovation rather than innovation. Advisors already have established processes for managing client assets.
“They don’t want to spend hours filling out an application,” she says. “They don’t want to look at two different screens to see the full picture.”
Nicolarsen finds that without the broker-dealer infrastructure that traditionally supports annuity transactions, RIAs need insurers to provide more of the operational support themselves. A fee-based product may remove the compensation obstacle, but it does little good if the advisor still faces an unfamiliar application process and cumbersome servicing requirements.
Jackson has focused on helping advisors manage annuities within their existing workflows, offering solutions that “integrate and are more in line with the client’s overall portfolio.”
Some practical barriers remain. Fee withdrawals must comply with tax rules, while insurance and securities licensing requirements can complicate transactions. Carter says outsourced insurance desks are helping firms address licensing requirements without having to maintain all the necessary expertise internally.
Competitive returns alone may not persuade RIAs to adopt annuities. Products must also be straightforward to administer within the advisory relationships firms have already built.
What retirement income needs from product designThe case for greater flexibility becomes clearer when considering how long an annuity may remain in force. Lake describes a client purchasing a contract at age 58 but waiting another decade to begin drawing income. “I imagine in that decade, 58 to 68, a lot of stuff’s going to change in my life,” he says. Retirement plans may shift, health circumstances can change, and family obligations may look different by the time withdrawals begin.”
“The hardest thing an advisor is asked to do is plan today for a 35-year retirement,” he says. A suitable contract therefore needs “enough simplicity for the advisor to be able to explain it” while still providing guarantees the client can rely on.
Nicolarsen believes manufacturers are responding with fewer restrictions and more choice. “There is a tremendous amount of increased flexibility, not only for the advisors but also the clients,” he says. Shorter surrender periods have made contracts more accessible, while some advisory products have eliminated surrender periods altogether.
Still, most buyers are approaching or already in retirement. “We’re not really seeing many 40-year-olds purchase these products,” Carter says. Her experience points back to the demographic opportunity facing insurers: a growing population that needs retirement income, alongside a sizeable group of advisors who have yet to embrace the products intended to provide it.
Winning advisors’ confidence beyond the contractGreater flexibility also puts more pressure on insurers to help advisors understand and manage the contracts they recommend. Carter says integration with financial planning software has improved considerably, allowing annuities to appear alongside other investments in consolidated reporting. But she wants systems to go further, showing guaranteed withdrawals and benefit values rather than simply the current account balance.
Delaware Life uses AI in actuarial work as well as to analyze feedback from approximately 385,000 policyholders. Lake also wants to use it to identify advisors whose practices resemble those of existing Delaware Life distributors, reasoning that they may serve clients with similar insurance needs.
Meanwhile, a more fundamental change is taking place in the companies providing the guarantees. Lake cites figures showing that the number of private equity-owned insurers rose from 16 in 2011 to 93 in 2025, with their market share increasing from approximately 2.5 percent to 20 percent.
advisors who remain reluctant to recommend annuities. Insurers have grown substantially by selling more to an established distribution network, but reaching firms outside it will require greater confidence in both the products and the companies behind them.
The industry’s sales growth has given insurers considerable room to experiment. Lake’s challenge is to direct more of that effort toward the advisors they have yet to persuade. For those advisors, a new feature or higher rate may be worth examining, but neither resolves the practical demands of recommending a contract that could remain in a client’s retirement plan for another five to 30 years.
What will win over more advisors?
Simpler products
Contracts that balance understandable features with dependable retirement income guarantees
Delaware Life is a life insurance and annuity company that empowers financial professionals with a wide array of customizable solutions. A subsidiary of Group 1001, we were born out of the advisor industry, and we understand how important it is to find the right fit for every client, every situation, and every individual need. We’re passionate about equipping you with annuities that give your customers peace of mind and a successful future - allowing them to plan with confidence for whatever’s next.
Brian Nicolarsen began his career in financial services in 2006 and joined Jackson as an Internal Wholesaler in 2007. Since then, he has served in a variety of roles of increasing responsibility, including business development consultant and regional vice president. In his current role as VP head of Jackson’s wirehouse and regional broker/dealer sales, Nicolarsen is responsible for managing the regional vice presidents.
Nicolarsen earned a bachelor of science degree in business from the University of Northern Colorado and a master of business administration (MBA) degree from the University of Colorado. He holds FINRA Series 7 and 63 registrations.
Jackson National Life Insurance
Brian Nicolarsen
For more than 20 years, Belle Carter has been proud to work in the annuity industry, with nearly a decade focused specifically on advisory annuities. As a key account manager at MassMutual Ascend, Carter oversees relationships with RIAs, OIDs, and technology partners, while collaborating with industry leaders and peers to advance the growth and adoption of advisory annuities.
Earlier in her career, Carter partnered with advisors to integrate annuities into their technology platforms and was resourceful in assisting advisors performing trades through a proprietary platform. Carter also served as a business development consultant and wholesaler for a leading annuity provider. She is passionate about innovation, collaboration, and helping advisors better serve their clients.
MassMutual Ascend
Belle Carter
Colin C. Lake is a seasoned financial services professional with 30 years of industry experience. As president and CEO of Delaware Life Marketing, he is dedicated to developing the next generation of leaders and helping sales professionals excel. His career includes 13 years at Planco/The Hartford and eight years at Guardian/RS Investments. In 2015, he founded DtNL and Developing the Next Leaders to tackle challenges in hiring, training, and retaining future talent. Beyond work, Lake is a devoted husband of 25 years, father to three teenagers, an avid endurance athlete, a voracious reader, and a committed advocate of wellness retreats and workshops.
Delaware Life Marketing
Colin Lake
Share
Published November 16, 2026
“[Advisors] don’t want to spend hours filling out an application. They don’t want to look at two different screens to see the full picture”
Belle Carter,
MassMutual Ascend
Greater flexibility
Shorter surrender periods and more adaptable withdrawal options
Seamless integration
Fee-based contracts, streamlined applications, and consolidated portfolio reporting that fit existing advisory workflows
Long-term confidence
Greater transparency around insurer financial strength, investment risk, and the ability to honour guarantees over decades
The retirement wave
More than 4.1 million Americans are expected to turn 65 annually through 2027.
What’s driving
annuity demand?
The pension gap
Just 24% of baby boomers reaching retirement age have defined benefit pensions.
Product momentum
FIAs and RILAs have helped fuel strong annuity sales growth by offering varying degrees of downside protection and growth potential.
Their expansion has put pressure on established insurers to compete more aggressively on investment returns. Lake acknowledges the benefits of that competition but warns that pursuing higher returns could introduce additional risks. “With that disruption and potential for more risk-taking, you may have fallouts or unintended consequences,” he says.
A competitive crediting rate may make one contract more attractive today, but the insurer’s ability to honour its obligations matters long after that initial rate has expired.
That consideration brings it back to Lake’s concern about